Protect What Matters Most
At Bacarella Insurance Group, we believe insurance is more than just a policy—it is a promise of protection, security, and peace of mind. As a locally owned, independent agency, we do not believe in one-size-fits-all coverage. Instead, we take the time to truly understand your unique life, family, and business goals, matching you with tailored solutions from the nation's leading carriers.
Whether you are insuring your first home, expanding your business, or looking out for your family's future, we are committed to being your advocate, your advisor, and your neighbor every step of the way.
Meet Our Team
Home, auto, condo, rental, flood, and RV coverage tailored to your life in Southwest Florida.
Protects your primary residence, detached structures, and personal belongings from covered perils like fire, windstorms, and theft.
Learn More
Covers financial losses from car accidents, theft, and vehicle damage, including liability for damage you cause to others.
Learn More
An essential separate policy covering a building's structure and contents from water inundation—vital for coastal Southwest Florida.
Learn MoreGeneral liability, commercial auto, property, and more—built to protect your business.
Protects your business from financial loss if you're held legally responsible for third-party bodily injuries or property damage.
Learn More
Safeguards your company's physical assets—buildings, inventory, and equipment—from fire, theft, and windstorms.
Learn More
Covers medical bills and lost wages for employees injured on the job, and shields your business from related lawsuits.
Learn MoreCoverage that helps with the cost of extended care as you age—protecting your savings and easing the burden on your family.
Coverage that helps pay for the cost of extended care as you age, protecting your savings and easing the burden on family.
Learn More“Bacarella Insurance Group exceeded my expectations in every way. They not only helped me find the perfect coverage but also made me feel genuinely heard and valued as a client. Their expertise allowed me to save money without compromising on protection. I highly recommend talking to John or Timmy, you won't be disappointed.”
— Andrew V“Our family just moved to Fort Myers and needed to get auto insurance. Jonathan was the first agent to actually answer his phone. He got us a quote that fit our needs and budget, so he got our business. Jonathan so far has been very professional and easy to work with.”
— Ron H“Bacarella Insurance Group is an absolutely outstanding insurance company. They always put the clients' needs first. Bacarella found us a better homeowner's policy with better coverage at a lower premium when a past renewal came up. All the staff are professional and cordial in every way!”
— Therese H